Each tag adds a percentage on top of the points of the cards that meet it. The tier goes up with the number of cards.
Each card is worth points for its rating and rarity: special and holographic cards are worth more. Each active tag adds its tier percentage only on top of the points of the cards that meet it. For "same" tags (same nation, same club), the group that earns the most counts. For "different" tags, one card of each counts. The total of points plus bonuses decides the grade, from D to S.
Cards from the same country.
Different Nation
One card from each country counts.
Cards from the same club.
Different Club
One card from each club counts.
Cards from the same league.
Different League
One card from each league counts.
Bronze cards (rating up to 64).
Silver cards (rating 65 to 74).
Golden
Gold cards (rating 75 or higher).
Holographic versions of special cards.
Iconic
Icon cards.
Heroic
Hero cards.
TOTW
Team of the Week cards.
Cards you packed or earned (SBC, objective, reward), never bought on the market. 5 to 9: +150%; 10 to 19: +300%; 20 or more: +500%.
Hands Only
Goalkeepers, including as an alternate position.
Multiples!
Different versions of the same player.
Ambidextrous
Cards with a 5-star weak foot.
Skilled
Cards with 5-star skill moves.
Defensive Wall
Center backs and full backs (CB, LB, RB).
Midfield Control
Midfielders (CDM, CM, CAM, LM, RM).
All out Attack
Strikers and wingers (ST, LW, RW).